The U.S. well being secretary says he needs to shift habit care towards an method that features rural farms or camps for folks in restoration. Many habit consultants say the concept is outdated.
JUANA SUMMERS, HOST:
Well being Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is going through new criticism for his plan to assist individuals who use road medication with a community of government-run farm and work camps. Kennedy has pointed to at least one drug therapy neighborhood in rural Italy as a mannequin for this system. He is additionally stated the camps might be a spot the place American kids might be, quote, “reparented.” NPR habit correspondent Brian Mann studies.
BRIAN MANN, BYLINE: When Kennedy campaigned for president in 2024, one among his signature coverage concepts was constructing a community of wellness farms and habit therapy camps in rural communities throughout the U.S.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
ROBERT F KENNEDY JR: I’ve seen this lovely mannequin that they’ve in Italy referred to as San Patrignano, the place there are 2,000 children who work on a big farm.
MANN: That is Kennedy talking on the community NewsNation in 2024. As well being secretary, Kennedy’s imaginative and prescient of wellness farms, particularly these he proposed for youngsters, is below scrutiny with Senator Angela Alsobrooks, a Democrat from Maryland, questioning him throughout a combative Senate listening to final week.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
ANGELA ALSOBROOKS: You stated each Black child can get reparented on a wellness farm. Are you able to admit that you simply stated that?
MANN: Throughout the heated alternate that adopted, Alsobrooks described Kennedy’s idea as harmful and irresponsible. Kennedy pushed again.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
ALSOBROOKS: Nicely, I’ve the recordings, really.
KENNEDY: I’ve no reminiscence of claiming something like that.
MANN: Kennedy later added, quote, “if I stated it, I apologize.” In truth, Kennedy did communicate at size about reparenting American kids on U.S. government-run farms throughout not less than two totally different podcast appearances when he was campaigning. At occasions, Kennedy described it as a method to assist a variety of youngsters harmed by habit and what he described as overprescription of hysteria and melancholy medicines. However throughout an interview on a podcast referred to as “Excessive Stage Conversations,” Kennedy spoke particularly about his imaginative and prescient for Black kids.
(SOUNDBITE OF PODCAST, “HIGH LEVEL CONVERSATIONS”)
KENNEDY: And people children are going to have an opportunity to go someplace and get reparented, to dwell in a neighborhood.
MANN: NPR requested repeatedly to interview Kennedy about his views. The Division of Well being and Human Providers despatched an emailed assertion acknowledging Kennedy used the reparenting time period however stated his feedback about Black kids had been taken out of context. The HHS assertion stated Kennedy used the reparenting time period in reference to psychotherapy therapy. However through the podcast interview, Kennedy made clear his inspiration was the Italian farm camp.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
KENNEDY: The mannequin for this can be a neighborhood that I had direct contact with due to household.
MANN: HHS officers advised NPR Kennedy would haven’t any additional remark about his curiosity in San Patrignano. However we have been in a position to go to the neighborhood east of Florence, on Italy’s Adriatic coast, the place we interviewed quite a few residents and staff about this system created within the Nineteen Seventies. Leaders at San Patrignano advised us they have been shocked and confused by Kennedy’s enthusiasm. They haven’t any report of him ever visiting or contacting them to find out about their program. Monica Barzanti, San Patrignano spokeswoman, stated she solely discovered about Kennedy’s imaginative and prescient for copying their mannequin by means of the media.
MONICA BARZANTI: Yeah, I learn the interview as a result of somebody forwarded me. It’s the solely factor I find out about this mission.
MANN: Maybe on account of this lack of contact, Kennedy has talked about San Patrignano as an answer for the U.S. habit disaster whereas continuously getting primary details concerning the neighborhood fallacious. We discovered San Patrignano is way smaller and has fewer residents than Kennedy suggests. He is additionally described it as a spot that primarily serves kids. In truth, the overwhelming majority of residents are grownup males. San Patrignano does have a farm and vineyards and textile workshops like this one, the place we met Liliana Moretti, who’s 28. She stated her habit started after she was put up for adoption as a toddler.
LILIANA MORETTI: I had scars which have I by no means healed or healed not effectively, not sufficient, that I patch up with alcohol with, you realize, cocaine, with meals, largely.
MANN: Moretti has lived in California and Italy. And she or he’s been at San Patrignano for eight months. The day we met, she was weaving on a loom.
MORETTI: I am placing the thread across the wheel. I’ve to comply with a sequence of three orange threads.
MANN: Roughly 850 folks dwell right here. Most, like Moretti, do not obtain formal remedy or medical care. As an alternative, this system focuses on laborious work, a extremely regimented schedule and a deep concentrate on neighborhood.
MORETTI: This place has humanity, it has compassion. It has these little issues that assist you to see hope in your self and in others.
MANN: Kennedy used heroin for greater than a decade, beginning when he was a youngster. He stated wellness and work-focused concepts like these at San Patrignano that promote abstinence from drug use helped him get well. However lengthy earlier than final week’s Senate listening to, Kennedy’s embrace of San Patrignano and the neighborhood’s method to habit care was sparking alarm amongst many docs, researchers and drug coverage consultants within the U.S. Critics level to the truth that San Patrignano’s program rejects use of scientifically confirmed medicines like buprenorphine and methadone, lengthy thought of the gold commonplace for treating opioids like fentanyl, heroin and ache capsules, that are the most important causes of overdose deaths within the U.S.
Dr. Robert Heimer research the effectiveness of habit therapies at Yale College College of Public Well being. He says pivoting the U.S. response to the fentanyl disaster away from a concentrate on medicines towards an abstinence-centered mannequin like San Patrignano can be harmful.
ROBERT HEIMER: That is very laborious to reply with out getting offended. We all know that abstinence-based applications fail again and again, usually in a short time.
MANN: Heimer is one among many researchers who discovered that opioid customers who enter abstinence applications like San Patrignano shortly lose their tolerance for opioids. Their our bodies change into extra susceptible, then they relapse at excessive charges, usually with catastrophic outcomes.
HEIMER: Your probability of dying was 70% greater than when you weren’t in therapy in any respect.
MANN: Throughout our go to, even lots of San Patrignano’s most ardent advocates voiced doubts about whether or not their program might be efficient within the U.S. For one factor, San Patrignano’s leaders say their program is not geared up to cope with the type of extreme habit and sickness brought on by road medication like fentanyl, methamphetamines and xylazine which might be widespread within the U.S. In Italy, the most typical road drug is cocaine. San Patrignano’s medical director, Dr. Antonio Boschini, additionally advised NPR it might be inconceivable for his or her small, grassroots mannequin of habit care to be safely scaled up into the type of nationwide program Kennedy has described. Boschini says San Patrignano tried to increase within the Nineteen Nineties, and the trouble was a catastrophe.
ANTONIO BOSCHINI: There have been an excessive amount of folks. Uncontrolled. And one particular person was killed in the neighborhood.
MANN: Throughout that period, San Patrignano was rocked by scandals, portrayed in a Netflix documentary sequence in 2020, that drew nationwide consideration throughout Italy. The neighborhood recovered by downsizing and making sweeping reforms. NPR may discover no cases the place Kennedy talked publicly about these controversies. Once more, he did not reply to our inquiries.
Kennedy’s views matter. As well being secretary, he would be the most influential chief within the U.S. shaping habit coverage. And he is promised huge adjustments. Earlier this yr, when he unveiled the White Home’s new $100 million habit effort referred to as the Nice American Restoration Initiative, his focus wasn’t on well being care or medicine, however on work, religion and abstinence.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
KENNEDY: That is the way you precipitate a non secular revitalization, a non secular renaissance, by reaching out to addicts on the road after which giving them secure lives.
MANN: However public well being consultants level out road drug deaths within the U.S. have really been dropping quick for years, with docs and researchers saying a lot of the advance has come by means of wider entry to habit therapy medicines.
Brian Mann, NPR Information.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
Copyright © 2026 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional data.
Accuracy and availability of NPR transcripts could differ. Transcript textual content could also be revised to right errors or match updates to audio. Audio on npr.org could also be edited after its authentic broadcast or publication. The authoritative report of NPR’s programming is the audio report.
