Dozens of people that grew up round Philadelphia realized many years later
they shared the identical organic father, a pioneering infertility physician.
Transcript
AILSA CHANG, HOST:
Final week, we started telling you an unique story a few long-held secret. It is about dozens of people that realized late in life that the dads who raised them weren’t their organic fathers. Seems they have been all fathered by the identical man, a pioneering infertility specialist. As a substitute of turning into consumed with anger and bitterness, these half-siblings did one thing surprising. They got here collectively and bonded. They’ve even had reunions. In our closing episode, NPR’s Frank Langfitt explains how these strangers fashioned a household.
FRANK LANGFITT, BYLINE: Brina is among the offspring of Dr. Charles Charny. Like another siblings, she requested NPR to not use her full title to guard the privateness of some members of the family. Brina is a retired school professor. She says when her half-brothers and sisters first noticed each other, many linked over shared bodily traits. She defined at a sibling lunch final yr in New York.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
BRINA: You already know, like Peggy (ph) and Paul (ph) and, I assume, additionally Larry (ph). There’s a couple of who’ve, like, actually excessive cheekbones, after which you’ve the Frankenstein brow. Plenty of us have, like, these large foreheads.
LANGFITT: Some additionally linked over the occupation they shared with the daddy they by no means knew – medication. Their organic father, Dr. Charles Charny, was a famend urologist who lived in Philadelphia. Gil Brodsky, a physician himself, talked about it at a sibling reunion this yr in Florida.
GIL BRODSKY: We have got, you already know…
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: Proper.
BRODSKY: …13 docs amongst us. And none of us – of the 13 of us – grew up in a household the place both father or mother was a physician. It is one of many attention-grabbing mysteries of the household.
LANGFITT: Like their organic father, lots of the sibs excelled academically. Gil studied medication at Harvard, as did his half-sibling, Scott (ph). When Gil attended the sibling get-together in 2018, he was shocked to run into Scott. He shared the story in an earlier telephone name.
BRODSKY: Once we went to my first reunion, Scott stated, I do know you. I stated, huh? He says, yeah, we have been in medical faculty. I used to be a yr behind you. We have been mates in Vanderbilt Corridor. So we talked about who our varied mates have been. After which he stated, who’d you exit with? And there have been a couple of that we had in widespread.
LANGFITT: Along with Harvard, different Charny sibs, as they seek advice from themselves, attended MIT, Yale, Penn and Johns Hopkins.
BRODSKY: We’re a really distinguished household. We have got X variety of medical doctors and authors and heads of educational departments and issues like that. And it is like, wow, that is my household.
LANGFITT: As extra half-siblings popped up on DNA web sites, Gil and others served as ambassadors, serving to newcomers grapple with the revelation.
BRODSKY: It wasn’t like, hey, I obtained to let you know this – one thing, fella. We attempt to be delicate about it, and there isn’t any disgrace. You already know, we’re proud to be who we’re.
LANGFITT: However first contact will be tough. How do you inform somebody their father is not who they assume he’s? Joe Lubeck is a Philadelphia neurologist. When he popped up on an internet site as a half-sibling, Gil contacted him. Joe knew he’d been conceived with the assistance of a sperm donor however didn’t but know who that donor was. Earlier than the 2 spoke, Joe discovered an outdated picture of Gil on-line. The resemblance was putting.
JOE LUBECK: It appeared like my school yearbook image. I could not imagine it. And I confirmed this to my spouse, and it was, like, holy [expletive].
LANGFITT: When Joe obtained on the road with Gil, Joe was on edge.
LUBECK: I obtained indignant as a result of I believed that Gil was going to inform me that his father, the one which raised him, that he had the privilege of rising up in the identical family with, was my sperm donor. And I used to be really relieved when he instructed me in any other case.
LANGFITT: Why?
LUBECK: Nicely, there was nothing that Gil had that I used to be actually disadvantaged of.
LANGFITT: Gil defined to Joe that he wasn’t alone. He was a part of one thing a lot bigger. After listening to this, Joe says he went from trepidation to pleasure. However some conversations with siblings backfired. Brina remembers reaching out to a half-sister after seeing her listed as an in depth relative on a DNA web site. Earlier than she spoke with Brina, the girl had no concept the person who had raised her wasn’t her organic father.
BRINA: She was very indignant. My different siblings instructed me that I might higher lawyer up, that I’ll get sued. And I am like, what can I be sued for?
LANGFITT: What was she indignant about?
BRINA: That I instructed her she was donor conceived. She had 4 cousins on the telephone drilling me and making an attempt to poke holes in my story to determine the place I used to be not telling the reality.
LANGFITT: Brina says the episode underscores simply how tough it’s to share a revelation like this with a stranger.
BRINA: She’s completely right. I have no idea. On the time I am speaking to somebody, I do not know who they’re, what’s taking place of their life, whether or not or not it is a good second to speak or not.
LANGFITT: Diane, who additionally requested that her full title not be used, is an creator and entrepreneur in Boston. She says different half-siblings rejected this concept of a brand new household as nicely.
DIANE: We now have 10 that actually don’t desire something to do with this. They’re indignant at their mother and father. They do not like us. They do not wish to interact.
LANGFITT: However for these raised as solely youngsters, the invention of so many half-siblings has been a beautiful shock. Larry Brook (ph) is a retired CPA. He is 81.
LARRY BROOK: There are negatives to being an solely little one. The largest unfavourable is you’ve no one to speak to. You may have no one to play with. I wished siblings rising up far more than some. I imply, I all the time wished a sister. I now have 30.
LANGFITT: The sibling reunions have now gone on for a decade. At January’s mini reunion in Fort Lauderdale, the siblings appeared like outdated mates or brothers and sisters. Someday, the siblings and their spouses shared lunch on a terrace. After lunch, Dena Harris, an OBGYN, caught up with me by a synthetic waterfall subsequent to the lodge pool. She mirrored on how the reunions and relationships have modified through the years.
(SOUNDBITE OF WATERFALL FLOWING)
DENA HARRIS: Now, it is evolving into a special sort of assembly the place we simply wish to have enjoyable with one another. That is all. So – and you might see we actually do like one another. We get alongside very well. It’s extremely weird.
LANGFITT: The Charny sibs have had time to ponder the which means behind their extraordinary expertise. Diane frames it like this.
DIANE: On the finish of the day, this complete story is about – what’s household?
LANGFITT: Diane now sees parenthood and household as outlined by love and nurture, not biology.
DIANE: I’ve no questions on who my father was. My father was not my sperm donor. My father was the man who taught me experience a motorcycle and who took me out for Chinese language meals on Sundays. That is my dad.
LANGFITT: Brina attracts a broader lesson.
BRINA: My complete life, the way in which that I’ve coped with issues which are tough or difficult is to have a look at it and say how can I make this work as one thing optimistic in my life? I am an enormous believer that we’ve got selections in how we could take a look at issues. And if one mind-set about one thing is not working, you’ve a alternative.
LANGFITT: A option to take a possible disaster and switch it into one thing affirming and significant. Frank Langfitt, NPR Information, Fort Lauderdale.
CHANG: Frank interviewed 18 members of the family over the previous yr for this story. You may hear a full model of this story on The Sunday Story on NPR’s Up First podcast.
(SOUNDBITE OF MARCOS VALLE, ET AL. SONG, “GOTTA LOVE AGAIN”)
Copyright © 2026 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional info.
Accuracy and availability of NPR transcripts could fluctuate. Transcript textual content could also be revised to right errors or match updates to audio. Audio on npr.org could also be edited after its unique broadcast or publication. The authoritative report of NPR’s programming is the audio report.
